Old Stone Oven Rectangular Pizza Stone Review

Old Stone Oven Rectangular Pizza Stone

Pizza stones typically come in a round shape. But some manufacturers disregard the traditional circular model to produce a rectangular pizza stone or square shaped ones. 

Whose sole purpose doesn’t involve only making these type of Italian dishes.

Old Stone Oven was the first to sell the round shaped pizza stone commercially.

But, the company has come a long way also to manufacture rectangular shaped models.

Some buyers prefer the rectangular model. While others stick to the original round model product, so ultimately the choice, in regards to shape, is up to you.

Old Stone Oven Rectangular Pizza Stone with pizza.

source: spinadeal.com

Old Stone Oven Rectangular Pizza Stone is the best-selling non-circular pizza stone on the kitchen supply market.

Therefore, it may be the exact model you have been searching for if you’ve been unsatisfied with standard round models.

Keep reading for a detailed review of Old Stone Oven Rectangular Pizza Stone.

About The Product

Typically people who have experience making these type of dishes at home know how to make the most out of Old Stone Oven products. 

Since they’re tailored for individuals who are familiar with the pizza making process.

They manufacturer a variety of models that vary in size, shape, and thickness.

You may be familiar with Old Stone Oven’s best-selling product called Round Pizza Stone. Which is best used for making large sized pies.

This model you’re reading about functions similarly to the Round model.

But, differs visually since this model is of a different size and shape.

In fact, this Old Stone Oven model comes in a rectangular shape.

Which means you have unlimited baking options since the large surface area is sufficient for more than pizza making purposes.

A rectangular shaped model functions optimally when used for other baking purposes. While the round version only bakes pizza best.

This particular model product has received mixed reviews from buyers. Because it is not as thick as other Old Stone Oven models.

The less thick feature makes it difficult for a beginner to get the hang of making an evenly heated pizza.

Therefore, those who are inexperienced in using these type of products should pay extra attention to the heating process.

It’s recommended to turn the pizza several times, so it absorbs heat from the model’s entire surface area to result in a uniformly crisp pie.

Once you get the hang of using Old Stone Oven’s product, you’ll be making these type of dishes as if you’re running a pizzeria.


  • Weight: 10 pounds
  • Dimensions: 14.5-inches by 16.5-inches
  • Rectangular shaped
  • Handmade in the USA
  • Grill & Oven Suitable
  • 0.8 inches thick
  • Heat Core Center


Who Is Old Stone Oven?

Old Stone Oven altered the pizza industry when it came out with the first model of this kind meant for household use about 40 years ago.

People were given the option to choose between making a pie in the comfort of their home or buying one from a pizzeria.

When their product first hit the market, people were amazed at how restaurant quality pizza was easily attainable inside their homes.

Nowadays,  they have only slightly changed the model design it originally released.

However, they did expand the types of models it manufacturers since now there’s more options than just the Round 16-inch Pizza Stone model.

Old Stone Oven’s Stone is the perfect example of how this brand creates products that suit all kinds of baking needs.

What’s The Design?

Let’s take a look at the design of this amazing product.

Size, Shape & Thickness

Before you go ahead and buy this excellent product, make sure you measure your oven cavity depth and width.

To ensure that this excellent product fits in your oven.

Old Stone Oven Rectangular Pizza Stone

source: spinadeal.com

With dimensions that measure 14.5 inches by 16.5 inches, their great product should fit most standard sized ovens.

However, you should measure your oven just in case.

In regards to this model’s thickness, the model has a surprisingly average thickness that’s not typical of Old Stone Oven products.

The product measures only 0.8-inches thick. While other more popular Old Stone Oven models have a thickness that measures at least one-inch deep.

The 0.2 inches doesn’t make much of a difference in regards to it’s durability.

Since it can still withstand temperatures reaching as high as 2000 degrees Fahrenheit.

The small inch difference does affect the product’s heat sink ability in the oven.

Since Old Stone Oven Rectangular Pizza Stone comes rectangularly shaped, its ability to distribute heat evenly isn’t as efficient as the heat emitted from a 16-inch Round model.

When it comes to baking anything other than these pies, the rectangular shape will come in handy. Since it’s not traditionally meant for these type of dishes but for bread and pastries.

Insider Thoughts

Buyers love this model because you can use it for more than pizza making purposes.

Which means you have a personal brick oven placed on the bottom rack of your standard household oven.


  • Fits most ovens
  • Versatile
  • Affordable


  • Semi-thin build
  • Not suitable for beginners

Buyer Advice

Based on positive customer reviews, this Rectangular Pizza Stone will elevate your baking capabilities.

To the point that your homemade pastries will taste as if they came straight from the bakery itself.

When you compare all the online retailers that sell Old Stone Oven’s models, Amazon is the most reliable vendor you can order from.

For under $40, this product will function as your primary baking tool that will last you decades.

My Verdict

This is the perfect product for those who are experienced using such baking tools and want to broaden their cooking capabilities to include more than just pizza.

Old Stone Oven Rectangular Pizza Stone with bread.

Keep in mind that if you only want to make pizza, they manufacturer models that are better suited for making pizza than pastries and bread. 

They all fall under the same price range, so you don’t have to worry about expenses since this is one of the more affordable models available on the market.

I would highly recommend buying this Rectangular Pizza Stone.

Especially if you want to expand and improve your baking skills, so they reach professional levels.

Make sure you also take a look at make best pizza homepage, as well as our reviews section for plenty of useful information on your oven pizza making journey.

Feel free to leave us any comments or questions below. and we will happily help you out.

Our Rating


Leave a Comment: