The Best Pizza Stone To Add To Your Kitchen

The Best Pizza Stone To Add To Your Kitchen

Buying the best pizza stone possible isn’t as easy as buying a set of plates for your home.

This is because you need to complete thorough research before you finalize your decision.

You don’t want to drop a lot of money on a product type that can’t even deliver the type of pizza you prefer to eat.

Different kinds of model types have features that result in various types of pies, so you should choose the best pizza stone that works to your needs.

For those who love thin and crispy crusts, either a stone or clay made model type will suffice and provide the pie you want.

If time is an issue, you can’t buy a version that takes an hour to heat up in your oven because you’ll probably never end up using it.

Before deciding on a model type, make sure you familiarize yourself with the procedure. 

Particularly, dictating how to use the particular product type you might be interested in.

More important than the time needed for the product type to function.

You should ensure that the size of the model of your choice suits the dimensions of your oven.

You can measure your oven cavity depth and width as a reference, so you don’t make the mistake of buying a product option that’s too large.

*Notice: On mobile devices, scroll right to see entire table.

On What To Pay Attention When Choosing Your Product

Keep reading for more information as to what product features you should make a note of.  Before dedicating yourself to your version of the best pizza stone.

Size & Shape

The best pizza stones come in varying sizes and shapes, which function to cook different types of meals that go beyond just baking pizza.

Most common shape model types come in are round, square, and rectangular and they all vary in size.

Before settling on the best pizza stone shape, knowing its measurements will dictate whether or not you can make use of it.

Buyers recommend measuring your oven cavity depth and width, so you have set parameters that your particular model needs to fall under.

The last thing you need is a product type that won't fit in your oven.

Rectangular shaped pizza stone.
The Best Pizza Stone To Add To Your Kitchen

The traditional shape of a pizza is a circle. Therefore, if your only goal is to bake pies, a round shaped model will suit your needs.

Furthermore..

This type of product can range from having a diameter of 10 inches to 16 inches, so you can make the ideal one-person pie or a pie for the whole family.

Square and rectangular product types can be used to make pies.

However, people frequently also take advantage of these type of products to bake bread or even pastries. 

For those who need to leave extra room on the product for the food to properly cook in, a rectangular model type works best.

In regards to the product's depth, you should make sure you know how deep the product is so you can cook your preferred type of pizza.

These vary in depth since they can measure anywhere between .25 inches to 1 inch.

The deeper the particular model, the deeper the pizza crust, so those who love Chicago deep dish pizzas should settle on a 1-inch deep model type.

These type of products have a thickness that usually falls under the measurements of 1/2 inch to 1 inch thick.

Keep in mind that the thicker the particular model is, the longer it'll take to heat up so you can make use of it.

Some one-inch versions take one hour to heat up before you can place your pizza on it.

Glazing

A lot of buyers have a difficult time choosing whether or not they want a model that is glazed or unglazed. But, at the end of the day, it’s up to the buyer’s preference.

Standard clay made models containing various natural materials such as clay, tile, and marble, which is typically marketed as being unglazed.

When a model is unglazed, it means that it functions to absorb moisture from the pizza dough while providing uniform heat.

Those who love thin and crispy pizza should look into unglazed model types since these are the ones that are more porous than glazed ones.

In fact, stone made model's porous nature helps to reduce moisture buildup.

Which results in a crispy crust that is often impossible to achieve without one of these products.

Glazed models are a modern attempt to innovate the traditional unglazed model that only produces pizza of a thin and crispy consistency.

A glazed version may confuse buyers since the model's primary function is to absorb moisture.

And...

Keep in mind that some glazed models aren’t entirely glazed, but are technically micro-crazed.

A product type that is micro-crazed means that there are small amounts of fine cracks present on the product itself.

Which promotes its ability to absorb some moisture, but not as much as an unglazed one.

Micro-crazed versions cannot be washed using soap and water since it still contains a slight porous quality.

If you were to wash this particular product with soap, you run the risk of having soap being lodged deep inside of it. Which can give your pizza a soapy flavor.

Pizza Stone Glazing.

There are versions that are fully glazed, which means that it has no porous features that work to absorb moisture.

The lack of pores also plays a role in your ability to easily clean and maintain a fully glazed model.

A fully glazed model is the easiest model to clean because you can use soap and water to give it a quick cleaning.

Most of these product options are actually dishwasher safe, so no effort is required on your part to clean a fully glazed version.

Thickness

The product type's thickness dictates the crispiness of your pizza. Specifically for stone made versions, you should buy one that measures 3/4 to 1 inch deep.

A thick clay version works to absorb heat better than one that’s less than 3/4 inch deep. Which results in a pizza that’s been exposed to uniform heat.

Steel and cast iron made models are typically more thick as well as heavier than other product types. Which results in professional quality pizza.

With some deep steel opyions, you have the chance to make a deep dish pizza. Which is often impossible to achieve with a stone or ceramic pizza stone.

Our Recommendations: Best pizza Stone reviews

Since you understand the basic features that dictate whether or not one of these products can deliver restaurant-worthy pizza.

Below are reviews of five options that can be considered the best pizza stones for you to choose from.

Only with a thorough understanding of these type of products you can find the best pizza stone suited for your baking needs.

In the price range that won't make a dent in your wallet.

Keep reading for detailed reviews of noteworthy options because one is bound to catch your attention.

For Oven And Grill: Emile Henry Pizza Stone

When looking for the best pizza stone that will prove to be the perfect addition that your kitchen was missing.

The best manufacturer to go-to would be one that has expertise in producing clay bakeware and cookware products.

Emile Henry is a manufacturer that has had over 100 years to perfect its kitchen tools, and it specifically only makes its products out of clay.

This means that Emile Henry Pizza Stone is a clay made model, and the clay used is one of a kind that you won't find in any other model.

In fact, Emile Henry models are handcrafted from Burgundy clay that is naturally found in a region of France where Emile Henry originates from.

The mineral-heavy Burgundy clay is blended with 100% natural ingredients that work together to create Emile Henry’s signature Flame Top feature.

This particular version is classified as having a Flame Top. Which refers to Emile Henry's revolutionary line of cookware that is guaranteed to be versatile, lightweight.

And, distributes heat evenly for the perfect golden pizza crust.

Features

  • Weight: Around 6 pounds
  • Diameter: 14.5 inches
  • Clean using soap and water
  • Suitable for Grills, Ovens, & Broiler
  • Micro-crazed glaze
  • Scratch resistant
Emile Henry Made in France Flame Top Pizza Stone on table.

source: kitchenkapers.com

Our Rating

What’s The Design?

Emile Henry's model claims to have a micro-craze glaze that lets the buyer know that the item is slightly porous.

Therefore, it will absorb some moisture from the pizza but not as much as an unglazed model type.

The micro-craze glaze still allows this particular product to deliver a crispy crust pizza while resisting any stain buildup in the process.

Most model types start to develop stains and scratches after heavy use.

But, the Emile Henry model has a micro-crazed glazed surface that prevents it from wearing down and sustaining damage.

In fact, the moment you take Emile Henry model type out of the oven with your finished pizza. You can go ahead and cut it straight on the product since scratching it is out of the picture.


Best Pizza Stone To Buy: The Pampered Chef model

For those who want the minimum amount of work in regards to making pizza.

You should choose a model that requires close to no effort on your part to deliver restaurant quality pizza. 

The Pampered Chef Pizza Stone is the ideal solution to minimize your time and effort spent cooking.

Features

  • No preheating required
  • Micro-craze glaze
  • Nonstick seasoning feature
  • Weight: 5 pounds
  • Diameter: 15 inches
  • Round Shape
  • ​Microwave Safe
  • Freezer Safe
  • Conventional & Convection Oven-Safe
  • Included: Pan Scraper
  • Made in the USA
  • Hand wash only
The Pampered Chef Large Round Stone with pizza being made.

source: pamperedchef.com

Our Rating

What’s The Design?

With most model types, you need to preheat the oven for at least 30 minutes before placing your pizza dough on it.

Model types with a 1/2 inch thickness take 30 minutes to reach 500 degrees Fahrenheit. While 1-inch thick model types can take up to an hour to fully heat up.

The Pampered Chef model eliminates the preheating process, so you can jump straight into setting your pizza up in the model type.

Once your oven reaches its designated temperature, you place the loaded pizza model on the rack.

And, within 5 to 10 minutes you’ll have pizza that’s ready for you to devour.

Similar to the previously reviewed option, The Pampered Chef model also contains a micro-crazed glaze.

Hence, this allows some moisture absorption but not a significant amount. 

The Pampered Chef describes this product as being virtually nonporous, which confirms the model type's in between glazed state.

You get all the perks of a glazed and a unglazed option in one product as well as shortened cooking time.

Which comes in handy if you’re always in a rush. Ultimately, it’s safe to say that this model type is one of the best pizza stone options in its price range.


Best Rated option: Old Stone Oven Round

Old Stone Oven revolutionized the kitchen supply industry when it made in-home pizza stones available for mass consumption around 40 years ago.

As time passed, technology continued to advance, which positively affected the the type of models Old Stone Oven produces.

Those specifically looking for a stone that replicates a pizzeria's standard large-sized pizza. Old Stone Oven Round Pizza Stone is the exact size of a large pie in which you would have to pay $15 for.

You can make one at home for less than half the price.

A typical size for a version that will feed a family should measure at least 16 inches.

Which is the exact diameter measurement of the Old Stone Oven Round version.

This means those weekly pizza deliveries will cease to occur since you will convert the kitchen to your very own pizzeria.

On top of  the Old Stone Oven Round Pizza model being the ideal pizza size, it is the best-rated model that replicates the environment of a brick oven so well that the pizza will taste similar to the one you buy from your favorite pizza guy.

Features

  • Weight: About 8 pounds
  • Diameter: 16-inches
  • Stone Made
  • Lead-free clays
  • Eight circular stone feet from oven rack balance
  • Maximum temperature: 2000 Degrees Fahrenheit
Old Stone Oven Round Pizza Stone top side.

source: fantes.com

Our Rating

What’s The Design?

If you specifically want a product type that best mimics a brick oven, Old Stone Oven's model is kiln-fired during the production process.

Which results in a product that replicates a brick oven.

In fact, the kiln-firing of Old Stone Oven Round's model ensures that the product can withstand high temperatures. And, handle drastic temperature changes without breaking or cracking.

Most people tend to leave Old Stone Oven Round's model on the bottom rack of their oven.

The only time you should take Old Stone Oven Round model out from the bottom oven rack is when you need to use it for cooking purposes.

In order to minimize the chance of you dropping and breaking it in half. A lot of buyers ended up breaking their product this way.

Even though the Old Stone Oven Round's version can withstand dramatic temperature changes when it's time to clean the product, make sure you leave it outside long enough.

Hence, it stabilizes back to room temperature. By doing this, you're going easy on the product, which guarantees it'll last you more than a couple of months.

Product types that lack the kiln-fired process tend to crack after slight usage, so you have the option to invest in a product type that will last you decades.

Or you can invest in one that will break after a month.

Out of all the reviewed manufacturers, Old Stone Oven is hands down the best pizza stone brand you can rely on for consistent professional quality pizza that will leave everyone asking for seconds.


Runner-up: Old Stone Oven Rectangular model

The best pizza stone rated for its ability to bake a large variety of pizza, bread, and pastries is hands down Old Stone Oven Rectangular Pizza Stone.

Previously reviewed was the round version of this model, which is an ideal choice if you only plan on making pizza.

Old Stone Oven Rectangular's model has a slightly different build and size when compared to Old Stone Oven Round version.

This particular product comes in a rectangular shape and is large enough to fit in most basic household ovens.

Keep in mind that not all ovens are made with the same dimensions. Hence the Old Stone Oven Rectangular model might be too large for your oven.

A good rule of thumb before you start shopping for one of these products would be to measure the oven cavity depth and width.

Thus, you can use those numbers as a reference point for when you're buying the best pizza stone possible.

Features

  • Dimensions: 14.5 inches by 16.5 inches
  • Weight: 10 pounds
  • Heat Core Center
  • Rectangle shaped
  • Handmade in the USA
  • Maximum temperature: 2000 degrees Fahrenheit
Old Stone Oven Rectangular Pizza Stone with pizza.

source: spinadeal.com

Our Rating

What’s The Design?

For those who value a product version with versatility above all other features, Old Stone Oven's Rectangular model offers the most baking options.

When compared to popular Old Stone Oven product options.

Old Stone Oven's Rectangular model has an immense flat surface area that makes it ideal for baking special desserts.

That would benefit in taste when baked at a brick oven type environment.

On top of pastries, this rectangular option can still make a restaurant-worthy pizza; it just requires more effort on your part to achieve such excellent results.

Those who have never used these type of products before will find Old Stone Oven's Rectangular version difficult to master.

Hence, the previously reviewed Old Stone Oven model will most likely suit your needs for the best pizza stone possible.

In regards to where you can place Old Stone Oven's rectangular version, you can choose between heating this model type in your oven or on your grill.

Which results in pizza of varying crust texture.

As you can see, the baking options are limitless when you use Old Stone Oven Rectangular's option.


Best Quality: Weber Pizza Stone

Out of all the product models reviewed above, Weber's contains the best pizza stone material since it is made out of cordierite.

Weber models of this product do not look like your traditional stone since it has a stainless steel exterior.

And, handles located on each side that gives it the appearance of a tray. 

Don't be fooled by its flimsy appearance because this tough product can take a couple of hits before it cracks.

Since each product material has set requirements to create the proper environment to make professional quality dishes. 

Weber's version of the product has requirements that optimize your ability to make these pies.

For best results using Weber's version of the product, you should preheat either your oven or grill to around 500 degrees Fahrenheit.

Once the oven is ready, you should place the model type right in the middle of the oven on the lowest rack for about 30 minutes.

If you're using a grill, leave Weber's model right in the middle for 30 minutes as well.

This 30 minute heating time frame is essential for the model type to absorb as much heat as it can.

So it can cook your pizza within minutes of it being placed in the oven or grill.

Features

  • Made with Cordierite
  • Dimensions: 4 inches by 14 inches by 14 inches
  • Weight: 9 pounds
  • Color: Stainless Steel
  • Diameter: 13.4 inches
Weber pizza stone.

Our Rating

What’s The Design?

Weber's model set itself apart from the rest of the reviewed options since it contains one unique feature that all the other models lack.

This particular model is built with cordierite. Which is known to be slightly more expensive.

As well as more durable when compared to both clay and stone made versions.

Cordierite is less likely to crack under drastic temperature changes since it’s extremely thermal shock resistant.

Which guarantees that Weber's model will last you a couple of years before it finally breaks on you.

Since Weber's model contains cordierite, it can handle the heat from both your grill and oven. Which gives you more cooking options you can dapple in.


Conclusion

Hopefully, you now have a deeper understanding of the best pizza stones on the market.

So you can quickly finalize your decision as to which option is best pizza stone suited for your baking needs.

Out of all the brands reviewed above, Old Stone Oven is the one that's most consistent with their product quality and costs the least.

I would recommend choosing at least one of the options reviewed above since these are guaranteed to provide high-quality results without damaging your wallet.

Leave a Comment: