Pizza Pan with Holes vs No Holes

Pizza Pan with Holes vs No Holes

Having the right pizza-making tools for your kitchen is essential as it will make a significant difference in the texture and taste of the dish.

For one thing, it will determine whether you will get a crispy crust or soggy center.

Therefore, if you are looking to cook delicious pizza for your family or customers, it is important that you choose the right kind of pan.

Pans are divided into two categories: pizza pan with holes vs no holes.

To help you choose the right kind for your needs, you need to understand the type of crust they produce, the material used in construction, and the kind of maintenance they require.

Thus, this guide will hopefully help you explore the nuances of the pizza pan with holes vs no holes debate.

Looking for the right pizza stone? Then take a look at one of these*

[tcb-script src=”” defer=””][/tcb-script]

Pizza Pans with Holes

A baking surface with holes is popularly known as a perforated pan. Here’s a popular option amongst pizza lovers.

This kind comes with gaps located at the bottom which then allows heat to transfer directly to the crust.

These products are usually made of aluminum for durability and the holes let the moisture escape. These factors will ultimately result in a crispier crust.

The holes also speed up the baking time. 

Pizza Pans with No Holes

An example of one with no holes is a regular solid stone like this one. This is a good option if you like your pie soft and chewy rather than crusty.

It takes longer for heat to transfer to these surfaces, thus slowing the overall baking process.

Comparison Between Pizza Pans with Holes vs No Holes

Surface style

The perforated baking pan is designed with holes at the bottom which promotes air flow so that the dough can cook evenly.

Thus, this will give you a perfectly cooked crust that is crispy and brown in color. Also, the holes enable moisture to escape and helps prevent the crust from getting soggy.

On the other hand, baking surfaces with no holes do not allow much air flow and this quality allows the dough to bake in a softer manner.

Since the heat is not evenly transferred, the toppings may not cook properly. This would be ideal if you prefer soggy centers.

Material used

The materials used to make the two types should be considered when making your decision.

For the ones with holes, they are covered with a thick layer of aluminum or aluminized steel.

These materials absorb and accumulate heat faster and distribute it so that the crust can cook uniformly.

Most non-perforated baking surfaces are made of a thicker material which absorbs and accumulates heat over a longer period.

Due to slower cooking, the sauce will soak into your crust resulting in a doughy and chewy crust. The material of the baking pan will depend on the type of crust you want.

Cleaning and maintenance

Taking proper care of your baking equipment extends their lifespan and prevents producing food with strange smells, appearances, and flavors.

When it comes to cleaning and maintaining a pizza pan with holes vs no holes, the non-holey ones are generally preferable.

This is because they are usually dishwasher safe and involves a more straightforward approach.

It can be difficult to clean baking surfaces with holes due to the residue and crumbs that get stuck in the holes.

This is especially difficult for models that are highly perforated. And, you may even have to use a toothpick to remove the sauce and cheese drippings.

Baking time

Choosing between a pizza pan with holes vs no holes will depend on how fast you want your dough to cook.

Baking using the former will take a shorter period since the surface absorbs high heat quickly.

Additionally, it ensures speedy baking by enabling hot air to get to the bottom crust.

Dough baked on solid surfaces may take a while to cook.

This is because it takes a longer time for heat to transfer to the solid baking surface and this slows down the baking.


Solid pans are known for their versatility and multipurpose functions. These pans can be used for both baking and serving the cooked dish.

You can also slice the pie on the same pan, as this cuts down on the required steps and saves time.

Furthermore, if the solid pan is non-stick, you won’t need to transfer the dough to the board; rather, you can slice it directly on the surface.

One disadvantage of the perforated pans is that they are not good for serving or slicing your baked goods.

The holes in the pan can cause the sauce to drip off when pizza is sliced misting the surfaces and floors. You can only use them for baking.

Looking for the right pizza oven? Then take a look at one of these*

[tcb-script src=”” defer=””][/tcb-script]

Which Pizza Pan to Choose

When it comes to choosing between a pizza pan with holes vs no holes, it’s important to keep in mind the type of crust that you prefer.

Both types of pans are great for baking pies. But, the perforated version is preferable if you value speed and evenness.

The best thing about this piece of equipment is that the openings release moisture allowing the crust to be crispier.

However, cleaning can be a problem since residue and food crumbs are likely to clog the holes.

Pizza pans without holes come in handy when you are seeking a more flexible solution for all your baking needs.

They produce soft and crusty pies, making them ideal for baking, slicing, and serving the pizza.


As you can see, both types will produce deliciously cooked pizzas. However, there are certain aspects that make both choices the better option.

Take these distinguishing factors into consideration to help you choose the right one for your needs.

For instance, if you are looking to make pizza with crispier edges, a solid pizza baking surface is the best choice for you, while the pizza pan with no holes is a great choice if you enjoy softer pizzas.

Either way, you cannot go wrong as long as you know what your specific needs are.

Leave a Comment: